CPG Metrics: Why Less KPIs is More for Massive Gains!

Sponsored by

Not All AI Notetakers Are Secure. Here’s the Checklist to Prove It.

You wouldn’t let an unknown vendor record your executive meetings, so why trust just any AI?

Most AI notetakers offer convenience. Very few offer true security.

This free checklist from Fellow breaks down the key criteria CEOs, IT teams, and privacy-conscious leaders should consider before rolling out AI meeting tools across their org.

Get the Security Checklist

Large consumer packaged goods (CPG) companies navigate a complex IT environment with numerous applications across functions. While enterprises typically manage over 20 business-rich data sources, sometimes exceeding 100, the key to success isn't just having more dashboards or KPIs for every single data point. Instead, the focus should be on a core set of around 20+ essential Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) strategically deployed across functional areas like finance, supply chain, sales, marketing, and HR. These fundamental KPIs are crucial for running the business efficiently and monitoring day-to-day operations. Beyond these critical metrics, the real power lies in enabling self-serve, ad-hoc, and exploratory analysis, particularly leveraging Natural Language Processing (NLP) to delve deeper into unstructured data and uncover insights. Furthermore, augmented analysis, powered by machine learning (ML) models, can automatically identify patterns and trends, fostering a more agile and data-driven culture without the need for a formal KPI or dashboard for every question. In the following sections, we will cover the main KPIs based on functional and cross-functional areas in CPG, which are system-agnostic and applicable to most enterprise CPGs.

Supply Chain & Logistics: 

This area covers planning and execution of material flows from suppliers through production to retailers. The goal is high service levels at low cost. Key KPIs include On-Time-In-Full (OTIF) delivery, forecast accuracy, inventory turnover, days-of-inventory (DOH/DIO), case fill rate, warehouse utilization, and transportation cost per unit. For example, tracking lead time and OTIF helps identify bottlenecks - if delivery is late or partial, that signals a bottleneck in production or distribution. Efficient analytics might highlight that low forecast accuracy in a region causes stockouts, so replenishment frequency can be adjusted. Use cases:

• Optimize replenishment: Use demand data and forecast metrics to adjust order frequency and quantity, reducing stockouts and excess inventory.

• Identify bottlenecks: Analyze OTIF and lead-time metrics to pinpoint slow processes (e.g. a congested warehouse or a late-running supplier).

• Benchmark performance: Compare plant or DC metrics (throughput, downtime, fill rate) across sites to highlight underperformers and spread best practices.

• Network optimization: Use transportation KPIs (cost per mile, route time, fill %) to redesign routes and mode choices (e.g. more full-truck loads) for lower cost.

Delivery & Fleet Operations:

This function manages finished-goods transportation and delivery fleets. The goal is route efficiency and reliable delivery. Typical KPIs include delivery cost per stop or per unit, truck utilization, driver on-time percentage, cases per route, fuel efficiency, and planned-vs-actual route time. For example, companies track order accuracy (correct product delivered) and on-time delivery rate to measure service quality. Fuel use, idle time, and maintenance stats help cut costs. Use Cases:

• Route optimization: Analyze delivery time and distance metrics to generate more efficient routes (fewer miles per stop).

• Predictive maintenance: Use vehicle telemetry to forecast breakdowns (e.g. engine hours until service) and schedule upkeep before failure.

• Real-time tracking: GPS and geofencing allow monitoring of trucks/drivers for schedule adherence and quick response to delays.

• Cost control: Monitor cost per mile or per stop and compare to benchmarks; investigate spikes (e.g. due to traffic or driver behavior).

Retail Execution / Field Sales:

Retail execution encompasses in-store activities to ensure products are displayed, priced, and promoted correctly. This includes replenishing shelves, enforcing planograms, auditing displays and promotions, and capturing store-level data via field reps. Key metrics include planogram compliance, share-of-shelf, on-shelf availability, out-of-stock rate, promotion execution rate, sales velocity, and visit frequency. For instance, a "retailer adherence" KPI measures how well a store follows planogram and promo rules. Use Cases:

• Shelf auditing: Field reps or AI-powered tools (image recognition) regularly scan shelves to flag missing/misplaced SKUs and non-compliant layouts.

• Store prioritization: Analyze SKU performance and compliance gaps to focus visits on high-potential stores needing action.

• Execution monitoring: Compare in-store sales data and displays against planograms to adjust tactics (e.g. rebalance inventory or training).

• Mobile order capture: Enable reps to place orders on the spot when restocking is needed, closing the loop between visits and inventory replenishment.

Sales & Commercial:

This area covers account management, channel sales, pricing, and trade promotions. Objectives include growth, profitability, and customer satisfaction. Common KPIs are sales volume by channel/region, revenue per case, gross profit, trade-spend ROI, promotion lift, and customer profitability (e.g. margin by account). For example, trade promotion ROI measures incremental profit generated by promotional spend. Another KPI is market share (our sales / total market sales) to gauge competitive standing. Use cases:

• Promo effectiveness: Evaluate each promotion's ROI by linking trade spend to sales lift. Use analytics to adjust future promo strategies (as in trade spend ROI calculations ).

• Customer segmentation: Rank accounts by net margin or revenue growth. Focus sales efforts on the most profitable or highest-potential customers.

• Forecasting & demand planning: Use historical sales patterns and market data to forecast demand per customer/region.

• New product rollouts: Predict a new SKU's success by combining early velocity and repeat purchase data (see Innovation below).

Marketing & Brand Performance:

This function drives demand and brand equity. Systems often include marketing automation, digital analytics, and brand tracking tools. Goals are awareness, consideration, and ROI on campaigns. Key metrics include brand awareness, trial/repeat rates, share-of-voice, social sentiment, ACV distribution, promo lift, CAC (customer acquisition cost), ROAS (return on advertising spend), and customer lifetime value. For instance, ROAS shows revenue per marketing dollar, and CAC gauges cost to acquire a customer. Use cases:

• Campaign measurement: Tie ad spend and impressions to sales lift. For example, compute ROAS and adjust channel mix (digital vs. traditional) based on performance.

• Targeting and insights: Use customer demographics and loyalty data to refine targeting. Analyze social media sentiment and brand awareness surveys to adapt messaging.

• Distribution analytics: Measure ACV (All-Commodity Volume) and penetration to ensure products reach key retailers and demographics.

• Real-time optimization: Adjust campaigns on the fly (e.g. shift spend to underperforming segments or geographies) by monitoring performance dashboards.

Innovation & Product Development: 

This area handles new product concepts, R&D, and innovation pipeline. Key goals are to rapidly validate ideas and scale successful products. KPIs include speed to market (time from concept to shelf), percentage of sales from new products, new-product distribution rate, trial-to-repeat conversion, and innovation margin versus core products. Use cases:

• Early launch scoring: Track initial trial rates and repeat purchases to rank new products. For example, NielsenIQ found that winners vs. losers diverge in as little as four weeks.

• Predictive analytics: Use machine learning on historical launch data to forecast which concepts are likely to succeed, guiding go/no-go decisions.

• Optimized rollouts: Adjust regional launch plans based on market feedback and retail interest, allocating production to high-response areas.

• Idea management: Analyze consumer test scores and competitive gaps to prioritize innovation projects.

Finance & Corporate:

Encompassing accounting, treasury, and corporate functions, this area focuses on financial health and compliance. Core KPIs include working capital metrics (cash conversion cycle, DSO/DPO, inventory days), COGS as % of revenue, gross and net margins, budget variance, cash flow from operations, and cost efficiencies. A shared ERP/BI system integrates data from sales, trade spend, inventory, etc., enabling live financial dashboards. Use cases:

• Working capital management: Monitor DSO (days sales outstanding) and DPO (days payables) to optimize cash flow. For example, identifying slow-paying customers by tracking high DSO.

• Trade spend analysis: Link promotional spend to actual shipments and revenue to detect leakage or overspending. Dashboards can show trade ROI and alert on anomalies.

• Cost control: Drill into COGS and overhead by product or plant. Identify cost drivers (e.g. raw material price spikes) and take corrective action.

• Compliance & reporting: Ensure accurate financial reporting and audit readiness by unifying data from all business units.

HR & Workforce:

Human resources metrics track talent and safety. Critical KPIs include employee turnover rate, time-to-fill positions, cost-per-hire, training hours, eNPS/engagement score, absenteeism rate, and safety incidents (TRIR/LTIFR). (Turnover rate, for example, is calculated as the percent of employees leaving during a period.). Use cases:

• Turnover risk prediction: Analyze engagement survey and performance data to flag employees likely to quit, enabling proactive retention efforts.

• Workforce planning: Use turnover and vacancy metrics to predict hiring needs and optimize staffing.

• Safety monitoring: Track incident rates and near-misses to improve training and reduce accidents. (High absenteeism can also signal morale or health issues.)

• Training ROI: Compare training hours and skill certification rates to improvements in productivity or error reduction.

Manufacturing & Production:

This area oversees plant operations. Core KPIs include Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE), throughput, cycle time, downtime by cause, first-pass yield (quality), scrap/waste percentages, and production schedule adherence. For example, OEE combines availability, performance, and quality into one percentage to benchmark plant efficiency. Use cases:

• Bottleneck analysis: Monitor OEE and downtime by machine to find and fix slow stations (e.g. add parallel lines or maintenance).

• Predictive maintenance: Use metrics like Mean Time Between Failure (MTBF) to forecast when machines will fail and schedule service to avoid unplanned downtime.

• Quality control: Track first-pass yield and defect rates so that quality issues are caught early. (For example, "First Time Right" is measured as good units/total units.)

• Resource planning: Adjust labor and shift schedules based on production volume forecasts. Use real-time data to reallocate capacity across product lines as demand changes.

Inventory Management & Warehousing:

This domain handles inventory levels and warehouse operations. KPIs include inventory accuracy, cycle counts, shrinkage rate, picking accuracy, order cycle time, perfect order rate, labor cost per case, and warehouse utilization. For instance, inventory accuracy is measured by comparing system counts to physical counts (high accuracy is critical to avoid stockouts). Use cases:

• Cycle counting: Perform targeted counts on high-value SKUs to maintain accuracy. Use accuracy metrics to trigger recounts for problematic items.

• Order fulfillment: Improve picking processes by monitoring pick rates and accuracy. Strive for a high perfect order rate (orders correct, complete, on-time).

• Space & load optimization: Measure throughput (orders or cases per hour) to gauge efficiency. Use on-time load completion and trailer fill rates to optimize truck loads and reduce outbound costs.

• Loss reduction: Analyze shrinkage and damage data to tighten security or supplier QC.

Cross-Functional Metrics:

Some KPIs span multiple areas. Examples include Perfect Order %, End-to-End Lead Time, Customer Satisfaction (CSAT/NPS), and S&OP adherence. For instance, the Perfect Order Rate (percentage of orders delivered complete, on time and without error) cuts across order management, warehousing, and delivery. Lead time measures the full order-to-delivery time. Tracking Customer Service Score or NPS captures end-customer sentiment. Other cross-functional measures might be SKU rationalization (weighing SKU count vs. profitability) or monitoring how often the sales-and-operations plan is followed. Together, these cross-cutting KPIs ensure that all functions remain aligned and responsive to customer and business needs.

Sustainability/ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance):

As consumers and regulations increasingly focus on sustainability, KPIs related to environmental impact, ethical sourcing, and social responsibility are becoming critical for CPG companies. Use cases:

• Carbon footprint per unit of production, water usage intensity, percentage of sustainable packaging materials, waste reduction rates, supplier ethical compliance scores, employee diversity metrics.

• Reporting and transparency for stakeholders, identifying areas for environmental impact reduction, tracking progress on ethical sourcing initiatives, improving brand image.

Customer Service Operations:

While customer satisfaction is touched upon, a dedicated focus on the operational aspects of customer service can provide deeper insights. Use cases:

• Customer inquiry resolution time, first contact resolution rate, customer support channel efficiency (e.g., cost per interaction by channel), complaint volume by product/category, customer churn rate (if applicable to service interactions).

• Optimizing customer support workflows, identifying common customer pain points, improving service agent training, reducing customer frustration.

Research & Development (R&D) Efficiency:

Beyond the innovation pipeline, specific metrics for the R&D process itself can assess its effectiveness and productivity. Use cases:

• R&D project success rate (percentage of projects that result in commercially viable products), cost per new product developed, time to patent/IP registration, number of new intellectual properties generated, R&D budget utilization.

• Streamlining the R&D lifecycle, allocating resources effectively to promising projects, fostering a culture of innovation, ensuring competitive advantage through new product pipelines.

Compliance & Regulatory Affairs: 

Beyond financial compliance, CPG companies face numerous regulations related to product safety, labeling, marketing, and more. Use cases:

• Regulatory audit pass rate, product recall rates (number, volume, cost), adherence to food safety standards (e.g., HACCP compliance), labeling accuracy rate, litigation related to non-compliance.

• Ensuring product safety and quality, maintaining regulatory adherence across all markets, minimizing legal and reputational risks, building consumer trust.

In conclusion, it's clear that large CPG enterprises operate within an ecosystem of immense complexity and data richness. However, the notion that managing this complexity requires hundreds of dashboards scattered across the organization is a misconception that often leads to data fatigue rather than clarity. The reality is that most CPG businesses can be effectively run and critical decisions made by focusing on a core set of perhaps 20 to 30 essential Key Performance Indicators. These fundamental KPIs provide the vital pulse of the business, enabling day-to-day monitoring and strategic oversight. Any further insights or deeper dives should be driven by ad-hoc, exploratory analysis, leveraging powerful tools like Natural Language Processing and augmented analytics. If these explorations consistently uncover substantial, business-critical trends or patterns, they can then be formally elevated to become new, official KPIs. The call to action is clear: it's time to move beyond the proliferation of 500 dashboards and embrace a more focused, agile, and impactful approach to data-driven decision-making in CPG.

About the Author:
Misagh Jebeli is an enterprise data architect and founder, exploring how AI and data-driven products are reshaping the CPG industry, from inventory and forecasting to brand strategy and product innovation. - Connect on LinkedIn

Resources:

1. Companies wade through 367 apps to get work done | CIO Dive:

   https://www.ciodive.com/news/IT-spending-enterprise-applications/638145/

2. How big is your tech stack, really? Here's the latest data... - Chief Marketing Technologist:

   https://chiefmartec.com/2023/04/how-big-is-your-tech-stack-really-heres-the-latest-data/

3. CPG KPIs: Measuring CPG Business Success | NetSuite:

   https://www.netsuite.com/portal/resource/articles/business-strategy/cpg-kpis.shtml

4. Delivery Logistics KPIs to Look Out for: https://dista.ai/blog/delivery-logistics-kpis/

5. The Most Important KPIs in Fleet Management | MICHELIN Connected Fleet:

   https://connectedfleet.michelin.com/blog/the-most-important-kpis-in-fleet-management/

6. How to Master Retail Execution: A Guide for CPG & Beverage Space: https://www.customertimes.com/blogs/how-to-master-retail-execution-a-guide-for-the-cpg-beverage-industries

7. Top 15 KPIs Every CPG Brand Should Track to Drive Growth in 2025: https://www.deskera.com/blog/cpg-kpis/

8. Top 10 CPG Data & AI Use Cases Driving Innovation & Profitable Growth | Informatica:

   https://www.informatica.com/blogs/top-10-cpg-data-and-ai-use-cases-driving-innovation-and-profitable-growth.html

9. The CPG Innovator's guide to vitality - NIQ: https://nielseniq.com/global/en/insights/analysis/2023/the-cpg-innovators-guide-to-vitality/

10. How to use HR data to analyze and improve absence and turnover indicators? - BPX:

    https://www.bpxglobal.com/en/how-to-use-hr-data-to-analyze-and-improve-absence-and-turnover-indicators/

11. 73 Essential Manufacturing Metrics and KPIs to Guide Your Industrial Transformation | NetSuite:

    https://www.netsuite.com/portal/resource/articles/erp/manufacturing-kpis-metrics.shtml

12. 40 KPIs Businesses Must Track to Gauge Warehouse Performance: https://legacyscs.com/warehouse-kpis-to-measure/